How to rent a car without surprise fees

The daily rate is the start of the bill, not the bill. Taxes, location fees and extras offered at the counter can add a large share on top. Almost all of it is predictable, and much of it is optional.

Compare the total, not the daily rate

Search results often lead with a low daily rate. Click through to the last screen before payment and compare the full totals. A car that looks cheaper per day can cost more once airport and local charges appear.

Airport locations cost more

Renting at an airport usually adds concession and facility fees that city branches don't charge. For a longer rental, a branch a short ride away can save real money. Balance that against the cost and time of getting there, and check the branch's opening hours, which are much shorter than an airport desk's.

Insurance at the counter

This is the most expensive decision you'll make at the desk, so make it before you arrive.

If you have confirmed cover elsewhere, you can decline politely. If you have no car insurance and no card benefit, buying the waiver may be the sensible choice.

Fuel

You'll usually be offered three options:

  1. Return it full. Almost always cheapest. Fill up near the return location and keep the receipt.
  2. Prepay a full tank. You pay for the whole tank and get nothing back for fuel left in it. It only works out if you return the car nearly empty.
  3. Let them refuel it. The per-gallon price is typically far above pump prices.

Tolls

Rental companies offer toll devices or plate-based toll programs, usually with a daily fee charged on top of the tolls, sometimes for every day of the rental once you use it. Before you travel, check whether your route has tolls at all, whether you can pay them online yourself, and whether your own transponder works in that state.

Drivers and age

One-way rentals, mileage and upgrades

Returning the car to a different location can add a drop-off charge, sometimes a large one. Most rentals include unlimited mileage, but confirm it, especially for vans, specialty vehicles and local-only deals. If the class you booked isn't available, the company should give you a larger car at the same price. An upgrade offered for a fee is optional.

Paying: credit card or debit card

The company places a hold on your card for the estimated total plus a deposit. On a credit card that just reduces your available credit. On a debit card it ties up real money in your account, and many locations add conditions for debit cards, such as a credit check or proof of a return ticket.

Protect yourself at pick-up and return

  1. Before you leave the lot, walk around the car and take a video with your phone, including the roof, wheels, windshield and interior.
  2. Make sure existing damage is written on the agreement.
  3. Photograph the fuel gauge and odometer at pick-up and at return.
  4. Return the car while the location is staffed if you can, and ask for a closed receipt.
  5. Return it on time. Many companies charge an extra day once you pass a short grace period.

The checklist

Want Aura to do this for you? Tell her what you need and your budget, and she'll compare the options and explain her pick. Meet Aura. If she sends you a link, it may be an affiliate link; see our Affiliate disclosure.

All guides