How to choose a hotel from a screen

You can't walk through the lobby before you book, but a listing gives away more than the hotel intends, if you know where to look.

Start with the map, not the photos

Location is the one thing a hotel can't fix. Open the map view and check three things: how far it really is to the places you'll go each day, what sits next door (a highway, a nightclub, a construction site), and how you'll get around. "Minutes from downtown" can mean by car, at night, with no traffic. Measure the walk yourself.

Compare the total price

The nightly rate is only part of the cost. Add:

United States rules now require the advertised price of a stay to include mandatory fees, but the breakdown still matters, and parking is extra almost everywhere. Compare totals for your whole stay on the final screen before payment.

Read the photos like a detective

Read recent reviews for patterns

Sort by newest, because hotels change with management, renovation and wear. Read the middle ratings first. One guest's bad night is noise; the same complaint from many guests is a fact. Search reviews for the things that would spoil your stay: "noise", "air conditioning", "clean", "bed", "elevator", "smell".

Pay attention to how management replies to complaints. A specific, courteous answer suggests a hotel that fixes problems. Silence or a copied apology suggests one that doesn't.

Know what star ratings mean

There are two different numbers on most listings. The guest score reflects what visitors thought. The star class (two-star, four-star) describes the level of facilities and service, and it's assigned differently from site to site and country to country. A well-run three-star can be a far better stay than a tired four-star.

Check the practical details

Compare booking direct

Once you've found the hotel on a comparison site, look at the hotel's own website. Hotels sometimes match the price and add something, such as breakfast, a later check-out or loyalty points, and changes are often easier to make when you booked direct. Comparison sites can be cheaper too, so check both.

The ten-minute check

  1. Map: the real distance, and the neighbors.
  2. Total price for the whole stay, with fees and parking.
  3. Photos of your actual room type, plus guest photos.
  4. Recent three-star reviews, and a search for your deal-breakers.
  5. Cancellation terms and bed type.
  6. The hotel's own site, for a direct price.

Want Aura to do this for you? Tell her what you need and your budget, and she'll compare the options and explain her pick. Meet Aura. If she sends you a link, it may be an affiliate link; see our Affiliate disclosure.

All guides