How to choose a carry-on suitcase
A carry-on has one job: fit in the overhead bin and survive being dragged over curbs for years. Most of the differences between bags come down to a handful of choices.
Size: check your airline first
There is no universal carry-on size. Many large United States airlines use a limit of about 22 by 14 by 9 inches, and that includes wheels and handles. Some airlines allow slightly more. Many international and low-cost airlines allow less and also weigh the bag.
Two things to know:
- Measure the outside. Sellers sometimes list the interior or leave the wheels out. Look for "overall dimensions".
- Buy for the strictest airline you fly. A bag that fits a smaller limit works everywhere.
Two wheels or four
- Four spinner wheels glide upright beside you through airports and down aircraft aisles with almost no effort. The wheels stick out, which makes them easier to damage and takes a little space from the inside. On a slope, the bag rolls away.
- Two recessed wheels handle cobblestones, curbs and rough pavement better, and they're protected by the frame. You pull the bag's weight behind you, which is more tiring over a long distance.
If you mostly travel through airports and hotels, choose four wheels. If you walk city streets with your bag, consider two.
Hard shell or soft
- Hard shells protect fragile contents and shrug off rain. Polycarbonate flexes on impact and springs back, so it resists cracking better than cheaper, stiffer plastics. Most open like a clamshell, so they need twice the floor space to pack, and they rarely have outside pockets.
- Soft bags in ballistic nylon or dense polyester have outside pockets for a laptop or jacket, squeeze into tight spaces, and usually open from the top. Good ones resist tears and scuffs very well. They're less protective of fragile things and can soak through in heavy rain.
Weight
Every pound of suitcase is a pound you can't pack, and it matters most on airlines that weigh carry-ons. Compare empty weights, and be wary of bags that feel solid in the store because they're heavy.
What breaks first
Suitcases almost never fail in the shell. They fail at the moving parts, so check these closely:
- Wheels. They should turn smoothly and feel firmly attached. Wheels fixed with screws can be replaced; riveted ones often can't.
- Telescoping handle. Extend it and wiggle it. A little play is normal; a lot of rattle is a bad sign. It should lock at more than one height.
- Zippers. Larger zipper teeth last longer. Run each zipper around a corner, where cheap ones snag.
- Carry handles. You need one on top and one on the side, firmly stitched or riveted, for lifting into a bin.
Inside
Compression straps or a zipped divider keep clothes from shifting. An expansion zipper adds space, but an expanded bag may no longer fit the size limit, so treat it as something for the trip home in checked luggage.
Smart features
Built-in batteries must be removable, because airlines require the battery to come out if the bag is checked at the gate. A simple pocket for your own power bank does the same job with less to go wrong.
Warranty
Read what the warranty covers. Some cover manufacturing defects only. A few cover damage caused by airlines, which is how most bags actually die. A long warranty that includes wheels and handles is worth paying for if you travel often.
A quick way to decide
- Look up the carry-on limit for the strictest airline you fly.
- Choose four wheels for airports, two for streets.
- Choose a hard shell for protection, soft for pockets and flexibility.
- Compare empty weights.
- Test the wheels, handle and zippers, or search reviews for those three words.
Want Aura to do this for you? Tell her what you need and your budget, and she'll compare the options and explain her pick. Meet Aura. If she sends you a link, it may be an affiliate link; see our Affiliate disclosure.